Showing posts with label book club. Show all posts
Showing posts with label book club. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 20, 2012

Some thoughts on Dickens

My first exposure to Charles Dickens was when I was six or so and KUTV aired Mickey's Christmas Carol. I thought the story was fun and loved it. I remember rewinding the tape so many times to rewatch our copy. I even remember the commercials that were on the program.  Anyway that was my exposure to Dickens until I was in fourth grade and my teacher gave me a copy of A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens for Christmas.  I was so excited to get home to read the story. I remember staying up late into the night to read and realizing I didn't like it. 

Most people would chalk this up to being ten years old when I read it but the problem is this never changed. It didn't change when I read Oliver Twist and Tale of Two Cities in high school. It didn't change when I read Bleak House in college. It may be blasphemous for an English teacher and major to say this but I hated Dickens. 

Wait I take that back. I don't hate him per se. I actually love his stories. I love watching the BBC/Masterpiece theater versions. I feel myself drawn in (even if they are basically the same story over and over again) and I love the characters. I just don't like his writing style.

Which brings me to why I am even posting this. My neighborhood book club announced they would be reading Our Mutual Friend for the month of March. I was super excited, not because I got to read Dickens, but because here was a book I could finally get on the Kindle for less then I could buy it. I downloaded it and went to work. Yeah it took me a week to get through the first twenty pages. I still couldn't slug through his style. 

So I went to my old standby, the movie. I am sitting here watching the movie getting ready to discuss a book I couldn't read at book club tonight. I'll be honest, I'll admit I didn't read it and outline the reasons why. I will also talk about how much I loved the story. How the story of redemption and love is incredible. How their is a kind Jew in the story...way ahead of the times there Dickens. How there are strong women...something he didn't do earlier in his career.  And, what I believe to be his greatest strength, taking seemingly random story lines and weave them together into a classic tale.

So I won't be picking up any other Dickens' books anytime soon but keep those BBC movies coming!